Minority shareholder protection is essential to corporate governance, particularly in companies where majority shareholders concentrate ownership and management control. Although company law recognises the principle of majority rule, the unrestricted exercise of majority powers may unfairly treat minority shareholders and adversely affect their financial and legal interests. These practices could include exclusion from management, improper allocation of shares, watering down of voting rights, diversion of corporate assets and denial of access to important information of the company. The Companies Act, 2013 provides for statutory protection against such practices under its provisions relating to oppression and mismanagement, i.e. under Sections 241 and 242. The National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) has been vested with the powers to examine grievances and to provide suitable relief to the aggrieved shareholders. The paper analyses the legal regime in India for the protection of minority shareholders with particular reference to the scope of oppression and mismanagement, the remedial jurisdiction of the NCLT and the effectiveness of existing statutory safeguards. The paper covers the important cases of Shanti Prasad Jain v. Kalinga Tubes Ltd., Needle Industries (India) Ltd. v. Needle Industries Newey (India) Holding Ltd., Dale & Carrington Investment (P) Ltd. v. P.K. Prathapan and Tata Consultancy Services Ltd. v. Cyrus Investments Pvt. Ltd. The paper also undertakes a comparative study of the legal approaches in the United Kingdom and Australia to find possible improvements in the Indian framework. The study shows that 1 Assistant Professor, School of Law, Vels Institute of Science, Technology and Advanced Studies, Chennai. 2 Assistant Professor, School of Law, Vels Institute of Science, Technology and Advanced Studies, Chennai. despite the Companies Act, 2013 providing substantial remedial powers, practical difficulties relating to eligibility requirements, evidentiary burdens, litigation delays, and share valuation continue to affect the effectiveness of minority shareholder protection. In an effort to strike a fair balance between majority control and minority shareholder rights, the paper recommends procedural improvements, transparent valuation mechanisms and stronger enforcement of tribunal orders.
Countries borrow, and sometimes they cannot pay back. When that happens, there is no bankruptcy court to step in, no single law to follow and no neutral referee. What exists instead is a mix of bond contracts, creditor clubs, policies of international institutions and a small number of court decisions. This article explains how that mix works, where it helps and where it fails. It looks at collective action clauses, the pari passu clause, the Paris Club, the IMF, the G20 Common Framework, national courts and investment arbitration, and it uses real cases from Argentina, Greece, Zambia, Ethiopia and others to test them. The article argues that the system is too slow, too scattered and too easy for a few creditors to disturb, and that ordinary people in debtor countries pay the price. It ends by weighing the main reform ideas and suggests a step-by-step approach that is realistic rather than perfect.
Arbitration is based on the twin pillars of independence and impartiality. Yet, as arbitration becomes more professionalized and commercialized, there are legitimate concerns about whether these values are being adhered to in practice. This paper explores the "neutrality paradox" of arbitration, i.e., the balance between impartial adjudication and the systemic pressures of a model where participation is far from equal. An important feature of the model is the "repeat player problem," where corporations, state entities, and institutions are regular participants, while individuals or small entities are sporadic participants at best. Such a model creates systemic pressures, especially in relation to the choice of arbitrators, where parties have influence over appointments. What are the implications of an arbitration market where reputation and the chances of reappointment are critical? What are the implications of "double hatting"? What are the differences between actual bias and perceived bias? Can the appearance of partiality negate the legitimacy of the arbitration process? What are the implications of recent institutional innovations in relation to disclosure of arbitrator appointments?
Leaving behind is indispensable for moving forward. It mainly applies to technological developments. To promote and achieve creativity and innovation, especially in the scientific field, the complete exclusion of damage may not be possible, but sustainable development is feasible. The resources of the future are guarded by sustainable development, thereby preventing the exploitation of natural resources and the environment. Both IPR and sustainable development are interconnected as they mutually support innovation. Economic growth is aided and challenges are addressed globally. IP assists research essential for sustainable development in fields like health and agriculture. Green technology promotes the mitigation of climate change and aids in the research of renewable energy. IPR offers protection against biopiracy and protects traditional knowledge. Indigenous communities often possess measures and suggestions for sustainable development. IPR makes sure that no developing country is exploited by a developed nation that has all the means to extract monetary benefits through knowledge of the developing nations. IPR offers coverage globally over products of innovation and creativity. It also facilitates the use of those products all across the world. It aims to uphold the concept of the "greater good." IPR acknowledges and distributes technology that supports sustainable development, but it condemns biopiracy. The indigenous communities that are victims of Biopiracy are exploited and left with no credit, authority, or monetary compensation. The WIPO supports the usage of IP in the public domain, but it also protects traditional knowledge through patents, copyrights, et cetera. This paper aims to discuss the persistent discourse between the goals of intellectual property and sustainable development. It also elaborates on how the theft of traditional knowledge affects people who possess concerned cultural and spiritual identities.
The Right to Information Act, 2005 gives an Indian citizen a legal route to documents that can explain why an office has delayed, refused or ignored a public duty. Whether this amounts to power over administrative inaction is a different question. The Act grants access to existing records and creates appeals, compensation and personal penalties for obstruction. It does not ordinarily permit an information commission to order an authority to issue a licence, complete a welfare payment or decide a pending representation. This article examines that separation by reading the statutory text alongside Supreme Court decisions and published evidence on the working of information commissions. It argues that the Act supplies an evidential and procedural form of accountability: it can make inaction visible, identify officials, expose departure from recorded rules and support proceedings under other laws. Its effectiveness is weakened where records are poorly maintained, proactive disclosure is neglected or appeals remain unheard. Recent changes to the personal-information exemption add a further question about the reach of scrutiny. The resulting account is conditional rather than celebratory: information can help citizens challenge administrative silence, but the legal duty to act must usually come from elsewhere.
Wesley Hohfeld's breakdown of legal rights into eight essential concepts has persisted for more than a hundred years, yet there is debate about its relevance in explaining contemporary rights. This article inquires if the framework continues to be analytically valuable for determining what current constitutional and statutory rights provide, to what extent the power & liability and immunity & disability relationships clarify protections that the terminology of right and duty may obscure, and where the framework encounters its limitations. Through an examination of legal principles and case law concerning Indian constitutional rulings and legislations, such as the Right to Information Act 2005, and notable cases including Navtej Singh Johar, Supriyo, Shayara Bano, Kesavananda Bharati, Puttaswamy, and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023, while contrasting these with the will-interest debate, Halpin's critical simplifications, and MacDonald's recent institutional analysis, this study posits that Hohfeld's framework is most effectively viewed as a diagnostic grammar of rights rather than a theory that provides justification. It reveals the underlying structure of combined rights, demonstrates that a significant number of constitutional guarantees act as immunities safeguarded by disabilities, and recognizes consent-driven systems as exercises of legal authority. It is least effective for positive rights that do not have a clearly defined duty-bearer and provides no insight into the rationale for the existence of rights. The article concludes by offering measured suggestions for legislative drafting and judicial reasoning.