The EU Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism and WTO Law: Legal Options for India
Manish Kumar SahuNov 21, 202610.5281/zenodo.24413922pp. 678–69417 pages
The European Union's Carbon Border Adjustment Mechanism (CBAM) entered its definitive phase on 1 January 2026, requiring importers of iron and steel, aluminium, cement, fertilisers, electricity and hydrogen to account for embedded emissions. For India, whose steel and aluminium exports to the EU are substantial, CBAM raises pressing questions of legality and strategy. This paper asks whether CBAM can be justified under Article XX of the GATT 1994 and what recourse India has. It argues that CBAM is best defended under Article XX(g), with Article XX(b) a weaker alternative, but that its vulnerability lies at the chapeau, in three implementation features: the default-value and verification regime, the asymmetric recognition of carbon prices paid abroad, and limited differentiation for developing countries. The paper then assesses India's options in light of the EU–India free trade agreement concluded in January 2026, which grants no CBAM exemption, and the WTO panel established in September 2026 in DS639, in which India is a third party. It contends that litigation offers India limited practical value while the Appellate Body remains inoperative, and that a combined strategy of third-party engagement, negotiated recognition of India's Carbon Credit Trading Scheme and verifiers, and prompt completion of domestic carbon pricing is more promising. The paper concludes with recommendations for Indian policymakers.
