Open Justice in the Age of the Search Engine: A Case Comment on Laksh Vir Singh Yadav v. Union of India (2026:DHC:4891)
Samreen NaushadNov 21, 202610.5281/zenodo.24413926pp. 695–7017 pages
In Laksh Vir Singh Yadav v. Union of India, the Delhi High Court decided a batch of over thirty writ petitions by persons whose names, tied to old judicial records and news reports, kept surfacing in name based searches long after the proceedings had ended. Sachin Datta J held that the right to be forgotten is a facet of informational privacy under Article 21, enforceable by writ even against private search engines and legal databases, but that the remedy is de-indexing from name based results and, in suitable cases, masking of identifiers, not deletion of the record. Relief is channelled into defined categories, chiefly acquittal, discharge or quashing, settlement, and purely private disputes. This comment argues that the central distinction between a record's existence and its retrievability by name is sound, but that the framework relies on outcome based categories, builds a right through adjudication while Parliament has declined to enact one, draws support from an intermediary rule that presupposes the order sought, and contemplates de-indexing across all versions of a search engine without a developed comparative justification. Its durability also depends on pending Supreme Court proceedings.
