Countries borrow, and sometimes they cannot pay back. When that happens, there is no bankruptcy court to step in, no single law to follow and no neutral referee. What exists instead is a mix of bond contracts, creditor clubs, policies of international institutions and a small number of court decisions. This article explains how that mix works, where it helps and where it fails. It looks at collective action clauses, the pari passu clause, the Paris Club, the IMF, the G20 Common Framework, national courts and investment arbitration, and it uses real cases from Argentina, Greece, Zambia, Ethiopia and others to test them. The article argues that the system is too slow, too scattered and too easy for a few creditors to disturb, and that ordinary people in debtor countries pay the price. It ends by weighing the main reform ideas and suggests a step-by-step approach that is realistic rather than perfect.
Arbitration is based on the twin pillars of independence and impartiality. Yet, as arbitration becomes more professionalized and commercialized, there are legitimate concerns about whether these values are being adhered to in practice. This paper explores the "neutrality paradox" of arbitration, i.e., the balance between impartial adjudication and the systemic pressures of a model where participation is far from equal. An important feature of the model is the "repeat player problem," where corporations, state entities, and institutions are regular participants, while individuals or small entities are sporadic participants at best. Such a model creates systemic pressures, especially in relation to the choice of arbitrators, where parties have influence over appointments. What are the implications of an arbitration market where reputation and the chances of reappointment are critical? What are the implications of "double hatting"? What are the differences between actual bias and perceived bias? Can the appearance of partiality negate the legitimacy of the arbitration process? What are the implications of recent institutional innovations in relation to disclosure of arbitrator appointments?
The Right to Information Act, 2005 gives an Indian citizen a legal route to documents that can explain why an office has delayed, refused or ignored a public duty. Whether this amounts to power over administrative inaction is a different question. The Act grants access to existing records and creates appeals, compensation and personal penalties for obstruction. It does not ordinarily permit an information commission to order an authority to issue a licence, complete a welfare payment or decide a pending representation. This article examines that separation by reading the statutory text alongside Supreme Court decisions and published evidence on the working of information commissions. It argues that the Act supplies an evidential and procedural form of accountability: it can make inaction visible, identify officials, expose departure from recorded rules and support proceedings under other laws. Its effectiveness is weakened where records are poorly maintained, proactive disclosure is neglected or appeals remain unheard. Recent changes to the personal-information exemption add a further question about the reach of scrutiny. The resulting account is conditional rather than celebratory: information can help citizens challenge administrative silence, but the legal duty to act must usually come from elsewhere.
#Right To Information Act#Administrative Inaction#Accountability
0 citations0 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Constitutional Law·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
Hohfeld's Theory of Jural Relations and Its Relevance to Modern Legal Rights
Wesley Hohfeld's breakdown of legal rights into eight essential concepts has persisted for more than a hundred years, yet there is debate about its relevance in explaining contemporary rights. This article inquires if the framework continues to be analytically valuable for determining what current constitutional and statutory rights provide, to what extent the power & liability and immunity & disability relationships clarify protections that the terminology of right and duty may obscure, and where the framework encounters its limitations. Through an examination of legal principles and case law concerning Indian constitutional rulings and legislations, such as the Right to Information Act 2005, and notable cases including Navtej Singh Johar, Supriyo, Shayara Bano, Kesavananda Bharati, Puttaswamy, and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023, while contrasting these with the will-interest debate, Halpin's critical simplifications, and MacDonald's recent institutional analysis, this study posits that Hohfeld's framework is most effectively viewed as a diagnostic grammar of rights rather than a theory that provides justification. It reveals the underlying structure of combined rights, demonstrates that a significant number of constitutional guarantees act as immunities safeguarded by disabilities, and recognizes consent-driven systems as exercises of legal authority. It is least effective for positive rights that do not have a clearly defined duty-bearer and provides no insight into the rationale for the existence of rights. The article concludes by offering measured suggestions for legislative drafting and judicial reasoning.
#Hohfeldian Analysis#Legal Rights#Constitutional Law
0 citations0 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Technology & Law·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
Deepfake and Personality Rights: An Emerging Cyber-IPR Conflict
Compassionate Appointment in Public Employment in India: Balancing Social Welfare and Equality of Opportunity under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution
Compassionate appointment occupies an uneasy position in Indian public service law. Conceived as an exceptional measure to relieve the immediate financial distress of families of government employees who die in harness or are medically incapacitated, it departs from the general rule of open, merit-based recruitment under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. This paper examines whether, and on what conditions, that departure is constitutionally defensible. Using a doctrinal methodology, it analyses constitutional provisions, service rules and judicial decisions, taking the Tamil Nadu Civil Services (Appointment on Compassionate Grounds) Rules, 2023, as amended in 2025, as a state-level illustration. It argues that the courts treat compassionate appointment as a limited, scheme-based welfare exception grounded in need, and not as a vested right. It shows, however, that the insistence on immediacy sits uneasily with administrative delay, that need is assessed through inconsistent proxies, that the authorities disagree on which version of a scheme governs a claim, and that the Supreme Court's two decisions of late 2025 are best read as addressing different claims and not as conflicting. The paper concludes that the exception can be reconciled with equality of opportunity only under clear, uniform and time-bound criteria, with reasoned decisions and consistent judicial scrutiny, and it offers nine reform recommendations.
#Compassionate Appointment#Public Employment#Articles 14 And 16
0 citations0 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Constitutional Law·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
Between Cure and Confiscation: Constitutional Boundaries of Retrospective Taxation and the Evolution of the 'Vested Rights' Doctrine in India
India's relationship with retrospective taxation is an enduring constitutional puzzle. Parliament and State legislatures indisputably possess the power to tax retrospectively, and the Supreme Court has, since the 1960s, treated the objection that a tax law 'operates in the past' as insufficient, in itself, to invalidate it. Yet the 2012 amendments that reversed Vodafone International Holdings BV v Union of India, the subsequent international arbitral awards against India, the statutory retreat of 2021, the 2025 legislative override of the Court's decision on input tax credit for 'plant or machinery' under the GST law, and the Supreme Court's 2026 decisions in Gameskraft and Asia Sugar all show that the doctrinal line between a legitimate 'clarificatory' or 'curative' amendment and an arbitrary, confiscatory re-writing of the past remains blurred. This paper reconstructs the evolution of the jurisprudence from its plenary-power origins through the validation cases, the reasonableness-of-retrospectivity cases, and the post-Shayara Bano doctrine of manifest arbitrariness. It examines, in particular, the intersection of retrospective fiscal clarifications with article 14 (equality and arbitrariness) and article 19(1) (g) (the freedom to practise any profession or carry on any trade), highlighting a neglected threshold problem: article 19(1)(g) is available only to citizens, so that foreign investors, and companies as such, must ordinarily rely on article 14, article 300A and the rule-of-law dimension of article 265. Drawing on comparative materials (the United States, Germany, the European Convention system and investment-treaty arbitration) and on the economic literature on legal transitions, the paper proposes a structured, six-stage Curative– Expropriatory Test: (1) genuineness of the defect or ambiguity; (2) removal of the juridical basis of any contrary judgment; (3) contemporaneous evidence of legislative intent; (4) weight 1 Fifth-semester law student, Dr Babasaheb Ambedkar School of Law, Rashtrasant Tukadoji Maharaj Nagpur University (RTMNU), Nagpur. and legitimacy of reliance interests; (5) proportionality of temporal reach, quantum and collateral consequences; and (6) a remedial principle of moderated retrospectivity, which severs punitive consequences and interest while upholding the principal levy. The test is applied to the 2012 amendments, to the 2025 GST override, and to the 2026 decisions, and a model statutory restraint is offered as institutional complement.
#Retrospective Taxation#Vested Rights Doctrine#Constitutional Law
0 citations0 downloads15 min readPDF Available
Human Rights·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
Women's Awareness of Property Rights and Available Legal Remedies
Artificial intelligence (AI) is rapidly transforming education through generative AI, adaptive learning systems, automated assessment, learning analytics and algorithmic decision-making. These technologies offer significant opportunities to expand access to educational resources, personalise learning and support teachers. However, their integration into education also raises fundamental human-rights concerns relating to equality, non-discrimination, privacy, human dignity, autonomy, accountability and meaningful participation. This article examines AI in education through the contemporary international human-rights regime, with particular emphasis on the right to education. It argues that the traditional digital divide is evolving into an AI divide: inequality increasingly concerns not only access to electricity, devices and internet connectivity, but also access to capable AI systems, digital and AI literacy, quality data, local-language resources and the institutional capacity to participate in and challenge AI-mediated decisions. Drawing upon international human-rights instruments, United Nations and UNESCO materials, African regional policy and recent scholarship, the article applies the availability, accessibility, acceptability and adaptability framework to AI-enabled education. It examines algorithmic discrimination, educational data, children's rights, human agency, teachers' roles, transparency and linguistic inequality. It proposes an eight-principle human-rights framework based on meaningful universal access, equality and non-discrimination, inclusion and accessibility, privacy and data protection, human agency and oversight, transparency and explainability, accountability and effective remedy, and participation. The article concludes that the legitimacy of AI in education should not be measured by technological sophistication or efficiency alone. Rather, AI should be governed as a means of advancing the right to education while preserving human dignity, equality and agency.
#Ai In Education#Right To Education#Algorithmic Discrimination
0 citations0 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Constitutional Law·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
Santhara Beyond Suicide: Constitutional Autonomy, Religious Freedom and the Limits of Essential Religious Practices
Indian courts addressing the Jain practice of Santhara (Sallekhana) have asked whether it is suicide, which Article 21 does not protect, or passive euthanasia, which Common Cause v Union of India protects under strict medical safeguards. This article argues that neither category fits. Both were built for clinical futility. Santhara is usually undertaken by people who are not yet dying and who are not under a clinician's care when the vow begins. The article traces the case law from Maruti Shripati Dubal to Harish Rana v Union of India (2026). It examines the stayed Rajasthan High Court decision in Nikhil Soni v Union of India. It separates Santhara from suicide, passive euthanasia, active euthanasia and physician-assisted dying. It also asks whether Santhara meets the elements of suicide under sections 107 and 108 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita 2023. The article then argues that the Essential Religious Practices doctrine should not decide individual cases. That doctrine asks whether a practice is theologically essential. The state's legitimate concern is capacity and coercion. Building on this point, the article proposes a capacity-and-coercion framework as a legislative option. The framework rests on capacity, voluntariness, reversibility and independent verification. It borrows procedural safeguards, and only those, from the Dutch and Californian assisted-dying statutes. The article tests the proposal against its strongest objections, including the 2025 death of a three-year-old child in Indore. It concludes that Indian law offers no adequate answer for the elderly, competent Jain adult who chooses Santhara. The article does not claim that the Constitution compels a specific outcome. Existing doctrine leaves the question open. The legislature, and eventually the Supreme Court in the pending Nikhil Soni appeal, should resolve it.
#Santhara#Sallekhana#Religious Freedom
0 citations0 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Human Rights·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
The Shrinking Public Sphere: Human Rights, Digital Citizenship & Mobility in Times of Crisis
The world is undergoing a significant crisis in the overall human rights landscape, marked by an alarming shrinking of civic space, where civil society organizations and those who hold dissenting views face an ever-increasing degree of repression, monitoring, and legalistic attempts at containment. As democratic backsliding gathers momentum worldwide, governments are using highly sophisticated measures, including everything from funding regulations to digital monitoring and harassment of human rights activists, to restrict freedom of association, assembly, and expression. This overall shrinking of civic space is an effort to silence any form of critical inquiry, accountability, and political opposition. This study will examine the complex relationship between the attempts by governments to restrict dissent and civil society's attempts at protecting human rights, with the overall thesis that the preservation of civic space is essential to the maintenance of democratic integrity and the attempts by governments to restrict dissent and civil society's attempts at protecting human rights, with the overall thesis that the preservation of civic space is essential to the maintenance of democratic integrity and the upholding of international human rights standards.
#Civic Space#Digital Citizenship#Human Rights
0 citations0 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Human Rights·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
A Critical Analysis on the Ethics of Biopiracy and Its Impact on Indigenous Communities
Leaving behind is indispensable for moving forward. It mainly applies to technological developments. To promote and achieve creativity and innovation, especially in the scientific field, the complete exclusion of damage may not be possible, but sustainable development is feasible. The resources of the future are guarded by sustainable development, thereby preventing the exploitation of natural resources and the environment. Both IPR and sustainable development are interconnected as they mutually support innovation. Economic growth is aided and challenges are addressed globally. IP assists research essential for sustainable development in fields like health and agriculture. Green technology promotes the mitigation of climate change and aids in the research of renewable energy. IPR offers protection against biopiracy and protects traditional knowledge. Indigenous communities often possess measures and suggestions for sustainable development. IPR makes sure that no developing country is exploited by a developed nation that has all the means to extract monetary benefits through knowledge of the developing nations. IPR offers coverage globally over products of innovation and creativity. It also facilitates the use of those products all across the world. It aims to uphold the concept of the "greater good." IPR acknowledges and distributes technology that supports sustainable development, but it condemns biopiracy. The indigenous communities that are victims of Biopiracy are exploited and left with no credit, authority, or monetary compensation. The WIPO supports the usage of IP in the public domain, but it also protects traditional knowledge through patents, copyrights, et cetera. This paper aims to discuss the persistent discourse between the goals of intellectual property and sustainable development. It also elaborates on how the theft of traditional knowledge affects people who possess concerned cultural and spiritual identities.
#Biopiracy#Indigenous Knowledge#Intellectual Property Rights
The path of transgender individuals from societal marginalization to political leadership highlights their growing representation and impact in governance. Transgender people are not just a part of the fabric of society, they are the fabric of society. Historically, transgender people have encountered structural obstacles to engaging in political affairs, such as prejudice, inadequate legal safeguards and widespread social bias. The rights of transgender individuals are safeguarded by various international and regional frameworks. However, discriminatory national laws, policies, and practices that target transgender people, such as burdensome procedures for altering identification documents, undermine their rights and hinder their access to justice. This leads to severe human rights violations by both state actors and society at large. Globally transgender people face profound social exclusion, which heightens their vulnerability to HIV, other health issues, including limited access to education and employment, and diminished opportunities for economic and social mobility. Furthermore, animosity and hostility toward those who challenge conventional gender norms often result in violent attacks against them. However, recent strides in legal reforms, human rights advocacy, and increased visibility have paved the way for transgender individuals to not only challenge these barriers but also step into leadership roles. This paper examines the challenges and opportunities in the inclusion of transgender voices in governance, highlighting case studies of transgender politicians and activists who have broken barriers to leadership. By analyzing the role of legal reforms, social movements and public awareness campaigns, it focuses on the inclusion of transgender individuals in governance as not only a matter of justice but also enriches democratic processes. In conclusion, the paper emphasizes the critical need for sustained legal, social, and cultural initiatives to ensure transgender individuals have equal access to political positions and leadership opportunities.
Generative artificial intelligence has changed how people prepare and share digital content. A user can now create or edit text, images, voices and videos within a very short time. These tools are useful in education, business, entertainment and many other areas. However, they can also be misused. For example, a person may use AI to imitate another person's voice, prepare a fake intimate image, spread a false video or support an online fraud. Such incidents raise an important question: who should be held criminally responsible when AI-generated content is used to harm someone?
The answer depends on the facts of each case. The person who gives the prompt, the developer who designs the tool, the organisation that uses it and the platform that shares the content may have different roles. This paper examines whether traditional principles of criminal law, including actus reus, mens rea, causation and individual responsibility, can deal with these situations. It follows a doctrinal and comparative method and considers selected legal developments in the European Union, the United States, the United Kingdom and the Council of Europe. A qualitative comparative matrix is used to examine the legal materials. The study finds that existing criminal laws can cover many forms of deliberate misuse, but practical difficulties remain in identifying offenders, proving intention, collecting digital evidence and investigating cases across borders. The paper argues that a balanced legal response should focus on the conduct and responsibility of each actor. It should protect victims without treating every error made by an AI system as a crime.
In India, the effects of a development project on nature and on people are judged in different rooms. Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) is carried out under the EIA Notification, 2006, by environmental regulators, for projects of a listed type and size. Social Impact Assessment (SIA) is carried out under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, by land acquisition authorities, and only when land is compulsorily acquired. This article examines what that separation costs. It identifies three problems: social harms that escape assessment altogether, consultation that is split across several forums, and decisions taken without a full view of a project's consequences. It reviews signals from the Supreme Court and the National Green Tribunal that environmental and social questions cannot be kept apart, and draws on the World Bank, the European Union and South Africa for workable models. It concludes by proposing five reforms that can be introduced within India's present constitutional and statutory framework, beginning with amendments to the EIA Notification that the Union can make on its own.
Suicide is a complex issue that continues to exist in Indian society even today. Some individuals may feel that ending their lives is the only way to escape the difficulties and challenges they are facing. When such an attempt does not result in death, it is considered an attempt to commit suicide. Over time, the law relating to attempt to commit suicide in India has changed considerably. Earlier, under Section 309 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860, an attempt to commit suicide was made a punishable offence, and this approach was often criticised because a person who survives a suicide attempt may already be facing serious emotional, social or personal difficulties and may require support and care rather than punishment. The Mental Healthcare Act, 2017 brought an important change by recognising the severe stress faced by persons attempting suicide and emphasising care, treatment and rehabilitation. Subsequently, the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 removed the general offence of attempt to suicide while retaining criminal liability only where the act is done with the intention of compelling or restraining a public servant from discharging official duties. This provision of BNS is particularly relevant to hunger strikes, which have historically been used in India as a method of protest to address grievances and demand governmental action. This article examines the changing legal approach towards attempted suicide and the legal position of hunger strikes in the context of criminal law and constitutional freedoms. It argues that a hunger strike should not automatically be treated as criminal offence and highlights the importance of examining the intention of the person and the circumstances of each case before applying Section 226 of the BNS.
0 citations0 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Technology & Law·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
Liability for Damage Caused by Private Space Activities: A Critical Analysis of the Private Autonomous Space Agency
Commercial space activity has shifted from state-led exploration to a mixed ecosystem of private launch providers, satellite operators, constellation managers, space-tourism ventures and increasingly autonomous systems. These actors create public benefits, but also expose people, property, aircraft, spacecraft and the orbital environment to risks crossing territorial boundaries. The legal difficulty is that the entity controlling an operational risk may be a corporation, while international responsibility and treaty claims attach principally to States. An individual whose property is damaged by debris cannot independently initiate a Liability Convention claim. This creates a gap between international responsibility, operator-level fault and access to compensation.
#Space Law#Private Space Activities#Liability
0 citations2 downloads13 min readPDF Available
Technology & Law·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
Trade-Based Money Laundering in International Finance: Legal Loopholes, Regulatory Challenges and the Role of Trade Finance
Trade-Based Money Laundering (TBML) disguises the proceeds of crime through legitimate cross-border trade by employing techniques such as over-invoicing, under-invoicing, multiple invoicing, phantom shipments, and misdescription of goods. Opaque corporate structures and divergent national regulatory frameworks further complicate its detection. Adopting a doctrinal approach, this article critically examines India's legal framework for combating TBML under the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002, the Foreign Exchange Management Act, 1999, the Customs Act, 1962, and applicable banking regulations, with reference to relevant Financial Action Task Force (FATF) standards. It identifies key regulatory weaknesses, including fragmented institutional oversight, difficulties in tracing ultimate beneficial ownership, reliance on trade documentation, and limitations in cross-border enforcement. The article also examines the dual role of trade finance instruments, particularly letters of credit and documentary collections, which facilitate international commerce but may also be exploited to legitimise suspicious transactions. It argues that statutory provisions alone are insufficient to address TBML effectively. An integrated, risk-based regulatory approach is necessary, incorporating coordinated enforcement, improved inter-agency information sharing, technology-assisted trade monitoring, greater corporate transparency, and stronger international cooperation.
The Right to Publicity has emerged as a significant legal concept in the protection of an individual’s identity against unauthorised commercial exploitation. An individual’s name, image, voice, likeness, and other distinctive attributes may possess substantial commercial value, yet their use without consent raises serious concerns regarding privacy, dignity, autonomy, and intellectual property. This paper examines the evolution and legal recognition of the Right to Publicity, with particular emphasis on the Indian legal framework and its comparative development in the United States and the European Union. In India, the right has primarily developed through judicial interpretation as an extension of the Right to Privacy under Article 21 of the Constitution, supported by principles of intellectual property protection and the common law of passing off. Landmark judicial decisions, including ICC Development (International) Ltd. v. Arvee Enterprises, D.M. Entertainment Pvt. Ltd. v. Baby Gift House, and Titan Industries Ltd. v. M/s Ramkumar Jewellers, illustrate the judiciary’s efforts to prevent the unauthorised commercial appropriation of personal identity. The paper further analyses emerging challenges arising from social media, artificial intelligence, deepfakes, digital avatars, and virtual platforms, which have made the reproduction and commercial exploitation of personal identity increasingly accessible and difficult to regulate. It also examines the tension between publicity rights and constitutionally protected freedoms of speech and expression, artistic creativity, satire, and legitimate public discourse. Adopting a doctrinal and comparative approach, the study argues that India’s existing fragmented legal framework requires greater clarity and consistency. It recommends the enactment of dedicated legislation defining the scope of publicity rights, establishing effective remedies, and incorporating appropriate safeguards for freedom of expression. The paper ultimately emphasises the need to balance commercial interests with individual dignity, technological innovation, and the fundamental principle that every person should retain meaningful control over the commercial use of their identity.
#Right To Publicity#Personality Rights#Commercial Exploitation
0 citations2 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Technology & Law·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025: A Legal, Constitutional, Social and Comparative Study
The transformation of entertainment through digital technologies has created a complex regulatory challenge for contemporary legal systems. Online gaming has emerged as an important component of India's digital economy, generating opportunities in software development, electronic sports, creative industries, digital entrepreneurship and technological innovation. Simultaneously, the expansion of online money gaming has raised serious concerns regarding financial vulnerability, compulsive gaming behaviour, consumer deception, data protection, cybercrime and the protection of minors. The conflict between economic innovation and social protection has consequently become a significant issue in Indian constitutional and regulatory law.
Against this background, Parliament enacted the Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Act, 2025, which establishes a national legislative framework for the development of electronic sports and online social games while prohibiting the offering, facilitation, advertising and financial processing of online money games. The Promotion and Regulation of Online Gaming Rules, 2026, which came into force on 1 May 2026, provide an implementation framework for the statutory scheme. The legislation represents a substantial departure from earlier approaches that frequently relied upon distinctions between games of skill and games of chance, as well as a fragmented combination of state gambling laws and general information technology regulations.
This paper critically examines the legislative objectives, institutional arrangements, prohibitions and enforcement mechanisms of the Act. Particular attention is given to the constitutional distribution of legislative powers under Articles 245, 246 and 248 and the Seventh Schedule; the relationship between Entry 34 of the State List and Entry 31 of the Union List; the freedoms guaranteed under Article 19(1)(g); the equality principle under Article 14; personal liberty under Article 21; and the implications of digital surveillance and search powers for informational privacy. The analysis also evaluates the relevance of leading Indian judicial decisions concerning gambling, games of skill, commercial freedom and proportionality.
A comparative assessment of the United States and the United Kingdom illustrates the different ways in which legal systems respond to online gaming risks. Whereas the United States combines federal restrictions with substantial state-level regulatory autonomy, the United Kingdom employs a licensing-oriented framework under the Gambling Act 2005. These approaches provide useful, although not directly interchangeable, models for evaluating India's prohibition-centred strategy.
The paper argues that protecting vulnerable users is a legitimate and important legislative objective, but the effectiveness and constitutional sustainability of regulation depend upon precise definitions, transparent classification, proportionate enforcement, procedural safeguards and independent review. It recommends a comprehensive regulatory approach incorporating evidence-based policymaking, safeguards against unlawful offshore operations, effective grievance redressal, privacy-preserving age verification, consumer education and periodic legislative evaluation. The central conclusion is that digital gaming governance must reconcile public welfare with constitutional accountability and technological development.
#Online Gaming Regulation#Digital Economy#Constitutional Law
0 citations0 downloads15 min readPDF Available
Policy·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
From Arbitration to Enforcement: How Are Arbitral Awards Enforced in India and Abroad?
Arbitration is often selected because it offers parties a private and comparatively flexible method of resolving disputes. Yet the value of an arbitral process depends not only on the tribunal's decision but also on whether the successful party can obtain the relief granted. This paper examines the legal journey from an arbitral award to its enforcement, focusing on domestic awards in India and foreign awards sought to be enforced in India. It analyses the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, particularly Sections 34-36 and Sections 44-49, alongside the Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards, 1958 (New York Convention). It considers the distinction between setting aside a domestic award and resisting enforcement of a foreign award, the limited role of public policy, and the Supreme Court's approach in Bharat Aluminium Co. v. Kaiser Aluminium Technical Services Inc., Shri Lal Mahal Ltd. v. Progetto Grano SpA, Ssangyong Engineering & Construction Co. Ltd. v. National Highways Authority of India, and Vijay Karia v. Prysmian Cavi E Sistemi SRL. The paper argues that Indian law generally supports finality while preserving safeguards for serious legal and procedural defects. Its central concern is the gap between an award becoming legally enforceable and the successful party actually receiving relief. It concludes that consistent judicial reasoning, proportionate case management, accessible procedural guidance, and effective execution practice are necessary to make enforcement more predictable without weakening legitimate safeguards.
#Arbitration#Enforcement#Arbitral Award
0 citations1 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Technology & Law·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
When AI Hallucinates the Law: Rethinking Professional Misconduct and Judicial Responsibility in India's AI-Assisted Courts
The paper highlights the issue of "hallucinations" of AI-aided Indian Judiciary, stressing on the landmark Supreme Court pronouncement in Pooja Ramesh Singh v. J&K Bank Ltd. (2026). The apex court has declared an absolute xero-tolerance standard for AI-produced unverified precedents, upholding those citations to be professional misconduct under Section 35 of the Advocates Act, 1961. The research paper examines the continuous tussle between the trap of efficiency of automatic legal research and the fundamental constitutional safeguards enshrined in Article 21, that includes the right of a fair trial and speedy justice. Comparing with international judicial pronouncements like the Mata v. Avianca, this study advocates that AI-produced unverified precedents divert the rule of law and vitiate the evidentiary efficacy of adjudication. At last, the paper argues for a strong regulation that makes human verification mandatory, protects judicial decision-making, and transforms judicial education to a antagonistic research pedagogy, guaranteeing that technology is a supportive mechanism that does not jeopardize truth and justice.
In July of 2026, the Supreme Court of India held that a decision based on an AI's hallucination as to what the law is, is "no decision at all." Although the Supreme Court made a good decision on a very limited constitutional basis, the Supreme Court's holding will be an ex post facto blunt instrument, unless there is a procedural obligation placed on the decision maker. Nullity is based on the constitutional rights to fair procedure (Articles 14 and 21) and the requirement of a reasoned decision. A default rule of nullity is better than a materiality test. The most appropriate response would be a technology-neutral duty to verify each authority relied upon against a primary source, to document that verification, and to notify the parties when the court relies upon authority that neither party has cited. When the Draft Regulations for Use of Artificial Intelligence in Courts (2026) are reviewed by the Supreme Court, the proposed regulations state that the verification exemption will not apply to legal authority.
#Judicial Duty#Fair Procedure#Ai Hallucination
0 citations1 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Constitutional Law·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
Beyond Gendered Protection: Reassessing the Need for Gender-Neutral Laws in India Through Constitutional Principles and Judicial Trends
The debate surrounding gender-neutral laws in India raises fundamental questions concerning constitutional equality, substantive justice, individual dignity and the scope of criminal liability. Indian legislation has historically incorporated gender-specific protections to address structural discrimination and gender-based violence. However, the persistence of gender-specific definitions of certain offences has generated concerns regarding the legal recognition of male and transgender victims, the scope of protection available to non-binary persons, and the relationship between protective legislation and equality before the law. The enactment of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), alongside contemporary judicial developments, provides a significant opportunity to reassess the adequacy of the existing framework. This paper examines the constitutional foundations of gender neutrality under Articles 14, 15 and 21 of the Constitution of India and analyses selected provisions of the BNS, the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005, the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, and the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012. It critically evaluates judicial developments in National Legal Services Authority v. Union of India, Navtej Singh Johar v. Union of India, Hiral P. Harsora v. Kusum Narottamdas Harsora, Joseph Shine v. Union of India and Janshruti (People’s Voice) v. Union of India. Particular attention is given to the tension between inclusive legal recognition and the continuing justification for special measures addressing gender-based disadvantage. The paper adopts a doctrinal and analytical methodology, supplemented by relevant empirical scholarship, to argue that gender neutrality should not be understood as the universal removal of gender-specific protections. Instead, it should operate as a context-sensitive legislative principle guided by the nature of the harm, constitutional justification, equality of access to remedies and the preservation of substantive protection for vulnerable groups. The paper proposes a framework for identifying unjustified statutory exclusions and advancing inclusive, effective and constitutionally defensible legal reform.
#Gender-neutral Laws#Article 14#Gender Justice
0 citations1 downloads15 min readPDF Available
Policy·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
The Unfinished Pillar: Negotiating the EU–India Investment Protection Agreement Between the Investment Court System and State-to-State Arbitration
The conclusion of the India–European Union Free Trade Agreement on 27 January 2026 left its investment pillar unbuilt. Investment protection was assigned to a separate Investment Protection Agreement (IPA), negotiated in parallel since June 2022 and still unconcluded. Meanwhile, European investments made in India after the 2017 termination of India’s bilateral investment treaties with twenty-two EU member states enjoy no treaty protection at all. This article examines the institutional question at the centre of the negotiation: whether disputes under a future IPA should be resolved by the European Union’s two-tier Investment Court System (ICS) or by the state-to-state mechanisms that now characterise India’s trade agreements. It traces the arbitral experience behind India’s 2016 Model Bilateral Investment Treaty, the constraints that EU constitutional law places on any dispute settlement design after Opinion 2/15, Achmea and Opinion 1/17, and India’s treaty practice through 2026, including the pending revision of its Model BIT. Drawing on the literature on institutional choice in investment law, it argues that the two positions are less opposed than the binary suggests. Both reject ad hoc, party-appointed arbitration, and both seek interpretive control by the treaty parties. The real obstacles lie in four narrower issues: exhaustion of local remedies, the taxation carve-out, most-favoured-nation treatment and the enforceability of awards in India. The article proposes a model of “sequenced standing adjudication” that combines dispute prevention, a time-limited domestic remedies phase and state-to-state filters with a bilateral standing court docked to multilateral reform.
The original handwritten Constitution of India contains a distinctive visual programme of illustrations accompanying its Parts. This article examines those illustrations as a possible visual vocabulary through which the Constitution may be read alongside ideas associated with ancient Indian jurisprudence. It focuses on Dharma, Raj-dharma, duties of rulers, welfare, pluralism, restraint in the exercise of power, and collective welfare, and considers how those ideas may illuminate the constitutional subjects placed alongside particular illustrations. The article argues that the illustrations are neither legally operative provisions nor merely ornamental artwork. They can instead provide historical and cultural context for understanding the constitutional imagination of the document, provided that symbolic interpretation is distinguished from demonstrable evidence of the framers' subjective intent. The article therefore develops a thematic reading of the illustrations in relation to fundamental rights, directive principles, federalism, local self-government, social justice, elections, emergency powers, and constitutional change. It also compares the Indian approach with selected constitutional traditions that incorporate civilizational or indigenous concepts. The study concludes that the illustrations enrich the historical understanding of Indian constitutionalism, but their interpretive value must remain subordinate to the constitutional text, structure, and established methods of legal interpretation.
#Ancient Indian Jurisprudence#Indian Constitution#Constitutional Illustrations
0 citations2 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Technology & Law·Volume 2·Issue 1
View
Banks' Liability for Unauthorized Electronic Transactions in India: A Study of Customer Protection in Digital Banking
India has made significant shifts towards digital banking, using UPI, mobile banking, cards and net banking to make payments faster and cheaper. However, as a result of these developments, the risk of banking fraud has shifted from the branch counter to the customer’s phone. In cases where a customer’s bank account is debited without her authority, the law in India attempts to answer the question as to who should bear that loss – the bank or the customer. This paper discusses the law on this issue in India. It begins by discussing the relationship between the banker and the customer, then analyses the Reserve Bank of India’s circular of 6 July 2017 on limiting the liability of customers. It also analyses the approach of the courts; in particular the Gauhati High Court and the Supreme Court in State Bank of India v. Pallabh Bhowmick. Furthermore, the paper investigates the remedies available to customers under the Consumer Protection Act 2019, the Information Technology Act 2000 and the RBI Integrated Ombudsman Scheme. Additionally, the paper evaluates the RBI’s 2026 amendment directions on digital fraud compensation for small values. The Indian law on this issue is also compared to the laws of the United Kingdom, the United States and Singapore. The paper argues that the 2017 RBI framework is sound in principle, but could be improved with more specific standards, better enforcement and changes to accommodate socially engineered fraud. Finally, specific suggestions are made for the reform of the digital fraud compensation framework.
Special Intensive Revision (SIR) and the Constitutional Protection of the Right to Vote: A Comparative Legal Study of the Balance between Electoral Roll Accuracy and Citizens' Democratic Rights, with Special Reference to Bihar and West Bengal
The foundation of a free, fair, and inclusive electoral system in India is a reliable electoral roll. The continued presence of deceased persons, duplicate entries, or other ineligible persons on electoral rolls may affect the integrity of elections. On the other hand, if the names of eligible citizens are erroneously deleted during the process of purification of electoral rolls due to faulty verification, documentary discrepancies, inadequate notice, or ineffective grievance redressal, citizens’ democratic participation may be adversely affected. The Special Intensive Revision (SIR) is an important example of this dual challenge. The present research paper examines the powers, procedural obligations, and voter rights of the Election Commission under Articles 324, 326, and 329 of the Constitution of India, the Representation of the People Act, 1950, and the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960. The empirical basis of this study comprises the SIR conducted in Bihar in 2025 and the revision process and related judicial proceedings conducted in West Bengal during 2025–2026. According to official data published by the Election Commission and the Government of India, approximately 7.89 crore electors were registered in Bihar on 24 June 2025, whereas approximately 7.24 crore electors were included in the draft electoral roll published on 1 August 2025. The final electoral roll published on 30 September 2025 recorded approximately 7.42 crore electors. In West Bengal, 7,66,37,529 electors were registered as of 27 October 2025, whereas the draft electoral roll published on 16 December 2025 recorded 7,08,16,630 electors. The press release issued by the Chief Electoral Officer of West Bengal on 28 February 2026 reported a total of 6,44,52,609 electors in the final roll. The differences among these figures must be understood in the context of the respective stages of revision, claims, objections, and cases pending adjudication. The validity of the Bihar SIR was upheld by the Supreme Court on 27 May 2026 in Association for Democratic Reforms v. Election Commission of India. In West Bengal, by contrast, separate judicial and administrative questions emerged concerning the implementation of the process, the large number of cases pending adjudication, the workload of appellate tribunals, and the functionality of the digital portal. According to reports published in September 2026 concerning information submitted by the Election Commission to the Supreme Court, approximately 38.20 lakh appeals relating to the West Bengal SIR had been filed, of which approximately 1.02 lakh had been disposed of. Reports published in October 2026 also indicated that certain tribunals had raised concerns regarding the issuance of notices, the conduct of hearings, and the restoration of names due to difficulties associated with the digital portal. Throughout this administrative process, and during the functioning of the Election Commission under the leadership of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, a prominent debate also emerged concerning the relationship between the Commission’s decisions and the alleged political interests and support of the current Modi Government at the Centre. Opposition leaders and parties—including Rahul Gandhi, Sanjay Singh, Mamata Banerjee, Arvind Kejriwal, and the Kakroach Janata Party (KJP)—staged strong protests against these revision exercises and levelled serious allegations that the Election Commission was working in favour of the ruling party. In contrast, the Modi Government at the Centre and the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) openly defended Gyanesh Kumar and the actions of the Election Commission, describing the exercise as a necessary measure to ensure electoral integrity. At the same time, a substantial section of the media, commonly referred to in public discourse as “Godi Media,” consistently adopted a position justifying and defending the actions of the Government and the Election Commission amid these controversies. The research examines these developments on the basis of official records of the Election Commission, judicial orders, political responses, and credible reports, classifying them according to different levels of evidentiary reliability. The central argument of the study is that electoral roll accuracy and the inclusion of eligible citizens are not mutually contradictory objectives. Achieving both requires transparent procedures, reliable verification, reasoned decisions, time-bound appeals, independent review, and publicly verifiable data.
0 citations1 downloads16 min readPDF Available
Technology & Law·Volume 1·Issue 3
View
Consent Is Not Control: Rethinking Individual Choice under India's Digital Personal Data Protection Framework
The growing use of digital platforms has made the collection and processing of personal data a part of everyday life. While consent is often treated as the primary means of protecting individual privacy, the reality is more complicated. Lengthy privacy policies, limited alternatives and unequal bargaining power can make it difficult for individuals to understand what they are agreeing to or to exercise genuine control over their personal information. This article examines the consent framework under India's Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, in light of the constitutional recognition of privacy by the Supreme Court in Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India. It argues that consent remains important but cannot, on its own, provide adequate protection in a digital environment where individuals may lack the information or practical freedom needed to make informed choices. The article therefore emphasises the need for clear privacy notices, responsible data processing, accessible grievance redressal and stronger institutional accountability. It concludes that meaningful data protection requires more than obtaining an individual's agreement; it requires a framework in which organisations are held responsible for how personal data is collected, used and protected.
#Digital Personal Data Protection Act 2023#Informed Consent#Privacy Notice
0 citations0 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Constitutional Law·Volume 1·Issue 3
View
From Discretion to Duty: Reconceptualising the Governor's Role under Articles 200 and 201 in Light of the Presidential Reference
The Governor's power over State Bills under Articles 200 and 201 of the Constitution of India has become one of the most contested sites of Indian federalism. In State of Tamil Nadu v. Governor of Tamil Nadu (2025), a two-judge Bench of the Supreme Court read timelines into Article 200 and, invoking Article 142, declared ten Bills to have received deemed assent. Months later, a five-judge Bench answering a Presidential Reference under Article 143 rejected both judicially fixed timelines and deemed assent. It held that the Governor has only three options, may exercise discretion in choosing among them, and is answerable only to a 'limited mandamus' for prolonged, unexplained and indefinite inaction. This article argues that the Reference, read carefully, does not restore unfettered gubernatorial discretion. By foreclosing the pocket veto and confirming that inaction is justiciable, it accepts the premise that the Governor's power is held in trust for the constitutional scheme. Drawing on constitutional morality, the federal structure recognised in S.R. Bommai, and the Constituent Assembly's understanding of the office, the article proposes a framework of 'duty-bound discretion' resting on four obligations: to decide, to give reasons, to act in good faith, and to act within reasonable time. It contends that this framework fills the space the Reference left open, gives content to the undefined limited mandamus, and points towards institutional reform, including a constitutional amendment prescribing outer time limits, as the legitimate path to the certainty the Court declined to supply.
#Governor's Discretion#Articles 200 And 201#Presidential Reference
0 citations3 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Policy·Volume 1·Issue 3
View
Greenwashing in Global Finance: An Analysis of the Role of International Treaties in Preventing False Sustainability Claims
Greenwashing occurs when financial products, companies, or institutions make misleading claims about their environmental sustainability. As more capital flows into assets labelled "sustainable," misleading claims have been sending that money to the wrong places, which reduces investor trust and weakens the climate goals that sustainable finance is meant to support. This article examines whether international treaties can effectively prevent false sustainability claims. It argues that the existing treaties, led by the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change and the Paris Agreement, set general duties for the states on the matter relating to climate action and transparency. However, these treaties do not establish direct rules for private financial entities. Therefore, the treaties work indirectly through national laws, regional regulations, and soft-law standards such as the IFRS sustainability disclosure standards and the guidance of the International Organization of Securities Commissions. By analysing legal aspects and comparing enforcement in the European Union, the United States, the United Kingdom, and Australia, the article highlights three key issues: There is no universally accepted definition of sustainable finance, enforcement varies across countries and remains inconsistent, and cooperation between regulators across borders is limited. It concludes that a new global treaty on this issue is unlikely in the near term. A more realistic approach is to build on existing treaty principles by recognizing each other's disclosure standards, strengthening regulator cooperation, and applying the international legal duties of due diligence and good faith.
India's 2025 Standard Operating Procedure for non-consensual intimate imagery directs significant social media intermediaries to detect recurring content through hashes and, where onboarded, to communicate collated hashes to the Indian Cyber Crime Coordination Centre. The February 2026 amendment reduces the complaint-based removal period to two hours, while Rule 3(1)(g) separately requires preservation of removed information and associated records for 180 days. These measures create a discrete evidentiary problem. A content match may justify renewed removal yet provides no standalone account of the particular upload, the responsible account or the system that produced an evidentiary output. Through doctrinal analysis of the IT Rules, the 2025 NCII SOP, the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam and the decisions in X v Union of India and Arjun Panditrao Khotkar, this article identifies a provenance gap between the reusable detection fingerprint and the individual dissemination incident. It proposes a two-record protocol linking a restricted prevention identifier to a separately preserved, event-specific record of each removal, with source-system information, integrity data and a lawful export pathway supporting Section 63 certification. The analysis distinguishes existing duties from proposed implementation specifications and confines its claims to what public legal materials establish. The resulting approach maintains rapid protection while preventing evidence of similarity from being mistaken for proof of personal attribution.
#Ncii#Provenance Gap#Content Matching
0 citations0 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Human Rights·Volume 1·Issue 3
View
Prostitution in India: Examining the Legislation Debate Through the Case of Sonagachi
The prostitution is not just current fire but it emerged from our historical roots. Prostitution is not just about sexual activity but activating the exponent of humiliation, mental cruelty and lowered self esteem. Irrespective of its negatives, it's thriving faster than the speed of light. The Human Trafficking Act claims to protect women from being trafficked, but are women safe enough? Is the act implemented with the right direction? The response of this question lies with the practices going under the noses of legislators, judiciary and law protectors. The researcher requests to consider sex workers under the category of profession marking how it is thriving in metropolitan cities. The researcher carries out the study about Sonagachi, an area infamous for the trade of girls for prostitution. The researcher in this manuscript pleads to make provisions for protection of sex workers and fights to grant them rights and protection. Legalisation of prostitution is a necessary evil as it will support the de-stigmatisation of sex workers in the future of India which will safeguard the dignity of women from sexual crimes.
#Prostitution#India#Sonagachi
0 citations0 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Human Rights·Volume 1·Issue 3
View
Reforming Juvenile Justice in India: Balancing Child Rights, Accountability, and Rehabilitation
The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015 allows a child aged sixteen or seventeen who is alleged to have committed a heinous offence to be tried as an adult after a "preliminary assessment" by the Juvenile Justice Board. This paper argues that the transfer mechanism is less a principled answer to serious adolescent offending than a legislative compromise whose costs fall on the procedural guarantees the Act otherwise extends to children. It reads section 15 against the Supreme Court's decisions in Shilpa Mittal and Barun Chandra Thakur, the age-determination case law, and the developmental research on adolescent culpability, and it engages the retributive and victim-centred case for transfer on its own terms. Accountability and rehabilitation, the paper contends, are not two poles to be traded off at a single age threshold. Both depend on institutional capacity that the system has never been resourced to supply: functioning Boards, trained probation staff, individual care plans that are actually followed, and aftercare that reaches young people beyond eighteen. Reform should narrow and proceduralise transfer, introduce statutory diversion, decouple offence classification from the general penal code, and treat implementation failure as a rights violation rather than an administrative shortfall.
#Juvenile Justice#Child Rights#Accountability
0 citations2 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Human Rights·Volume 1·Issue 3
View
Geographical Indications and Women's Economic Empowerment for Sustainable Development: A Comparative Study of Madhubani Paintings, Channapatna Toys, Pochampally Ikat, and Kashmir Pashmina Shawls
Although the "Geographical Indications of Goods (Registration and Protection) Act, 1999" does not specifically address women, who perform a significant portion of the labour in the crafts it protects, GIs are advocated in India as a tool for rural artisans engaged in manufacture of traditional artcrafts. In order to determine if registration has resulted in economic empowerment for women and advancement toward Sustainable Development Goals 5, 8, and 12, this research examines Madhubani Paintings, Channapatna Toys, Pochampally Ikat, and Kashmir Pashmina Shawls through lens of women worker participation, their contribution to the overall product, their economic benefit, if any received by women artisans directly attributable to the GI and the economic effect of honouring women exceling in their area of GI goods production by awards. It compares official data and open access studies with the Act, the Rules, TRIPS, the Geneva Act, and the European Union's 2023 proposed GI rule using a doctrinal and comparative approach. The four GIs are held or administered by state bodies or cooperatives. With authorised user registration remaining scarce and the evident concentration of women in low-margin stages of production the article attempts to throw light into the economic realities of women engaged in handicraft production due to non-recognition of their contribution and inaccessibility to the markets an area dominated by their male counterparts. Furthermore, the article provides suggestions to overcome the gender gap within the GI goods landscape.
#Geographical Indications#Women's Economic Empowerment#Sustainable Development
0 citations0 downloads14 min readPDF Available
Technology & Law·Volume 1·Issue 3
View
Who Is Minding the Algorithm? Section 166(3) of the Companies Act, 2013 and a Process Standard for AI-Assisted Board Decisions
Section 166(3) of the Companies Act, 2013 requires directors to act with 'due and reasonable care, skill and diligence' and to exercise 'independent judgment'. The provision was drafted for human decision-makers and is silent on what that duty demands when a board relies on an algorithmic system whose reasoning it cannot inspect. This article argues that the gap is practical, not theoretical. Indian courts have not fixed a consistent standard of care, the protections available to directors under sections 463 and 149(12) operate only after a dispute arises, and the regulatory material now addressing AI in Indian finance, from SEBI's 2025 consultation paper to the RBI's FREE-AI report and 2026 draft model-risk guidance and the Digital Personal Data Protection Act, 2023, binds entities rather than defining the individual director's duty of care. Drawing on Delaware's process-based oversight cases and on the distinction between substance and process in corporate governance scholarship, the article proposes a five-part Board AI Oversight Standard (identify, understand, challenge, monitor and document). It recommends two routes to give the Standard legal force: an amendment to Regulation 21 and Schedule II of the SEBI Listing Regulations, and a rebuttable presumption of due care under section 166(3) for boards that follow it. The proposal gives firms an ex ante and auditable benchmark for defending board decisions, and gives courts a workable test.
From June 2025 the Election Commission of India extended a “Special Intensive Revision” (SIR) of electoral rolls from Bihar to almost every State and Union Territory, requiring enrolled electors to re-establish eligibility through fresh enumeration and, if unlinked to an earlier intensively revised roll, documentary proof. In Association for Democratic Reforms v. Election Commission of India (2026), the Supreme Court upheld the exercise as traceable to Article 324 of the Constitution read with section 21(3) of the Representation of the People Act, 1950, found it proportionate, and recognised a “limited enquiry” into citizenship confined to electoral consequences. This article argues that the judgment settles the question of power but leaves three problems unresolved. First, by treating entries made through summary revisions as carrying only a rebuttable presumption, it relocates the burden of proving eligibility onto enrolled electors in a manner difficult to reconcile with Lal Babu Hussein v. Electoral Registration Officer (1995). Second, its proportionality review was largely retrospective: the safeguards that sustained the exercise were judicially supplied mid-stream, and the Bihar election was completed before adjudication, exposing a gap between roll revision and the finality Article 329(b) attaches to elections. Third, the open-textured phrase “in such manner as it may think fit” has enabled procedural law-making by administrative order and software, as the 2026 dispute over the Form 6 declaration illustrates. The article proposes statutory codification of special revision, a minimum pre-election interval, individualised deletion procedures, cohort-sensitive documentation, and a statutory purpose limitation on SIR data.
International commercial payments make the world go round, and Letters of Credit (LCs) are at the heart of it all, trusted by buyers and sellers everywhere. They’ve been the gold standard for minimizing risk in global trade, mostly thanks to the rules laid out in UCP 600. But times are changing fast. As trade moves online, we’re seeing everything shift: electronic documents, blockchain, fintech apps, digital banks. These new tools are great, but they’re also bringing a whole bunch of legal headaches, think questions about how to validate electronic documents, worries about authentication, cybersecurity, privacy, fraud, cross-border disputes, and keeping up with a patchwork of regulations. This study dives into the legal maze surrounding Letters of Credit in today’s digital economy, focusing on how international payments work now. It takes a hard look at big legal frameworks like UCP 600 and the UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Transferable Records (MLETR), plus Indian laws such as the Information Technology Act, FEMA, and various banking rules. The research spots some pretty serious gaps, showing that the current laws aren’t quite keeping pace with new digital risks. In the end, it calls for smarter regulations and fresh policies, so we can better control digital LCs, resolve legal uncertainties across borders, and make international trade safer, faster, and more reliable. All that, with the goal of protecting the integrity of global payments, even as technology keeps changing the game.
#Letters Of Credit#Digital Economy#International Commercial Payments